Template:S9 E5 Found

Judith passes out after revealing what happened. Maggie carries her out to the hospital, leaving Jesus alone to deal with the prisoner. He notices lacing on the back of her head, finally realizing the Whisperers are humans that disguise themselves as walkers.

Judith is being treated by Enid. Henry worries but Maggie reassures him. Soon enough, an outraged Tammy Rose, whose son Henry beat up, arrives with Morton and claims Henry tried to kill him. Henry stands up for himself and claims self defense, explaining that Morton attacked Judith, but Tammy does not agree, claiming that Judith attacked him. Henry protests, but Tammy claims Henry is dangerous.

Elsewhere, Jesus questions the Whisperer, who is revealed to be a 17-year-old girl named Lydia. Jesus asks her about the walker skin she was wearing, and she reveals that her group uses the skin to camouflage themselves from the dead, adding that they travel together for protection. When Jesus asks why, she explains that they need to live together with the dead, or not at all. Lydia assures him that his group will learn as well, or they will die, citing the first lesson the Whisperers are taught.

As Morton is being treated by Enid, Tammy Rose is still upset. Maggie assures her that Henry will be punished in some way, but points out that the beating her son sustained wasn't that much worse than the one Judith received from him. Tammy again claims Henry attacked Morton two days ago, causing Maggie to lose her temper and tell Tammy to go home. Tammy stands up to Maggie, demanding to be compensated for Morton’s "pain and suffering". She demands time-off from patrols, extra rations, improved living quarters and, lastly, for Henry to be locked away, but not before apologizing to them. Henry steps in and explains that Morton hurt Judith and would have hurt her worse if he hadn't intervened. Outraged that she wants him to apologize for saving his friend, he tells her: "You can go fuck yourself". Tammy attacks Henry, but Maggie breaks them up. She tells Tammy to go home, threatening to have her arrested if she doesn’t comply, while she takes Henry away.

Paul is surprised to learn that Lydia is so young. He deduces that there can't be that many Whisperers if they are sending children on the front lines. She corrects him by stating that childhood is a myth and that there are no "children" anymore. She asks why Jesus spared her life, but he answers that he's the one asking the questions. He asks why their group attacked them, but Lydia doesn't answer. Maggie escorts Henry to a cell and passes Paul interrogating Lydia, she ushers him into the cell next to them, as Henry wonders aloud why he is being punished for saving a life to which Maggie explains that he almost killed the boys and they won't kill anymore as Rick figured out after the war. She locks him in and goes to the cell next door to inform Jesus that Eduardo will survive. She asks about Lydia and the mask, so Jesus tells her about the Whisperers and how, when they first encountered them they thought the dead were talking. Maggie remembers what Ken told her and hurriedly drags Jesus away, leaving Lydia in her cell. Lydia starts a conversation with Henry through the adjoining wall, asking him if he did something bad and introducing herself. When Henry does the same, she smiles.

In her mobile home, Tammy is fed up with the way Maggie is running things and begins discussing how to handle Henry. In the corner, Gregory tells Tammy that the best solution would be to kill Maggie and have himself be the leader again, saying that Morton was nearly killed and Henry will be at dinner like nothing happened. Tammy balks at the idea and refuses Gregory's plan.

At the medical office, Marco explains to Maggie and Jesus that he had left Ken to die, and that he'd heard at least three Whisperers. Jesus deducts that it's the same group of people he had encountered, but it was odd that the group was so far away from where he'd been attacked. He then lets Marco know that the people were wearing suits of walker skin, and that he is not crazy.

Meanwhile, in the holding cells, Lydia asks Henry what he did to get imprisoned, or if he's just there to spy on her. Henry fills her in on the attack with Judith and Morton, and Lydia chimes back that the group makes less and less sense for throwing Henry in jail for defending a leader's daughter. Henry tries to defend his point by explaining to Lydia that his group is above killing now, and Henry reassures her that she will be forgiven. Lydia reveals that she was on her first outing and started to attack Jesus and his men because the rest of her group was attacking. He tells her that it was a misunderstanding and that maybe if she can tell Maggie more about the Whisperers, they can work things out. Lydia says that she wants to believe Henry, but she's too afraid.

Judith wakes up with Maggie by her side and asks if Morton is dead. When Maggie says no, Judith insists that her doors be locked. Maggie asks Judith to tell her what happened, and after she hears Judith’s story, she walks past Morton's room where he is sleeping and says "You fucking monster. I can't wait until you wake up." before walking away.

Paul is checking up on Eduardo, while Enid informs him Eduardo will live. Paul asks if Eduardo received his letter, to which Eduardo replies that he has, before kissing him. This shocks Paul, who asks if Eduardo read his letter, but Eduardo says they can still be friends.

Maggie opens Henry's cell and allows him to go free, but informs him that he will still be punished for what he did. As the two walk down the hall Henry asks Maggie to let Lydia go and to give her a chance to be a productive member. Maggie, however, denies the request after the ambush on Paul's group. Henry then pleads that they at least untie her as she is alone and her cell is locked.

In the forest outside of the Hilltop, two Whisperers keep watch over the community. One of them asks whether the Hilltop is the place that one (Paul) of their members was heading. The other assures him that it is and states that their leader is coming and that Lydia is strong enough to take care of herself as they wait in the bushes.

Meanwhile, back at Alexandria, Michonne and Magna are in the middle of harvesting corn for the winter and the upcoming festival when a worried Eugene walks past them. Michonne explains to Magna who he is and his situation with Rosita's pregnancy. Magna is curious why Eugene would be worried about having a child with the world they live in now when Michonne insists they drop the topic. Rick shortly appears after returning from the Hilltop and admits that he is a little worried about leaving Judith on her own and that it was hard for him to let her go. He is pleased to see Magna and Michonne getting along and asks how everything is going.

Tammy glares at Henry as he works with Earl. Earl lets Henry know that there is a bit of gossip going on about him and, though this is normal, he better watch himself. Henry goes back to the cells to talk with Lydia where he comforts her about her chances in Hilltop. He leaves her for a moment to collect something.

A vengeful Tammy makes her way to Gregory's trailer and tells him that she is willing to help Gregory reclaim his leadership position, but that they have to kill Henry as well.

Sitting outside Lydia's cell, Henry reminisces how he has survived the apocalypse and the obstacles he and his group have overcome. He states that because he has overcome some impossible odds, he has felt almost invincible. He tells her that he knows how insecure and scared she must be and that he has felt the same many times. He finishes that he doesn't believe in magic, but he can't ignore what he's lived through. He assures Lydia that if it has worked for him, then maybe it will work for her. Lydia smiles and thanks him for his advice.